← Back to session
Transcript March 12, 2026 · 10:30 PM

Thrive or Survive: Why Creativity is the Key to an AI-Future

A panel at SXSW 2026 exploring how over-reliance on AI is weakening human creativity, particularly for younger generations who may never develop the creative 'muscle' that comes from struggling with blank pages and unstructured problems. Panelists from Microsoft, Emory Law School, and education research discussed the neuroscience of creativity, the risks of cognitive atrophy, and what individuals, tech companies, and governments can do to preserve human creative capacity in an AI-saturated world.

creativity artificial intelligence brain development intrinsic motivation education workforce skills ai regulation adolescent development
Key Takeaways
  1. 1Always turn to yourself first before reaching for AI — the struggle of starting from scratch is what builds and maintains creative capacity.
  2. 2Brains develop in the ways they are used: outsourcing cognitive work to AI, especially during adolescence, risks short-circuiting the prefrontal cortex development essential for problem-solving and emotional regulation.
  3. 3The most important outcome of adolescence is not academic achievement but the brain you develop — unstructured play and passion pursuits are critical for building intrinsic motivation and stress tolerance.
  4. 4We need 'society in the loop' not just 'human in the loop' — governmental AI regulation modeled after seatbelt mandates can make the industry safer without destroying it.
  5. 5Human-generated work will remain the competitive differentiator — AI output is recognizable and less interesting than authentic human creativity.
Full Transcript

My name is Andrea Virgin. I was a former professional ballerina and civil engineer. Creativity made me the best engineer in South Florida, and it's something I'm deeply passionate about — bringing to more people the knowledge that creativity lives within all of us. We need to dispel the notion that some of us are creative and some are not. We are all creative.

Here at South by Southwest, a place to express and support creativity, I'm here with these amazing panelists to say that I feel a sense of weakening in my creativity over the last three years since AI was introduced. It's not to say that AI is a bad thing, but sometimes those quiet signals we feel need attention because they might be telling us something. I suspect by you being here, you might be feeling that quiet whisper that perhaps something's not quite right.

Think back to before AI was introduced three years ago, when you opened a blank document — an email, a presentation, a script. It was just you and that idea you were trying to get out of your head, with that familiar struggle, trial and error, frustration and tension of figuring out how to begin. Eventually you gave yourself patience and grit, and ideas started to flow. Now fast forward to today — it's you and AI, with endless possibilities and that frictionless start. But the question that's crept into my mind: if AI was suddenly unavailable today, would it be harder to start from scratch than it was three years ago? For me, it has. It's almost become automatic to begin with AI.

As adults, we can get back on the analog bike of creativity we grew up learning as children — we might be rusty, but we can get back on. But what about the generation growing up behind us, the ones becoming not just digital natives but AI natives? Imagine a kid today handed not the bike we grew up on, but an AI bike with a motor built in, perpetual training wheels, and a built-in GPS. They don't need the energy to take off, they'll never fall, and a prompt whisks them to a predetermined destination. So what happens to all that tenacity, rigor, failing, falling, wandering and exploring?

First up, we have Mike Pell from Microsoft, a futurist, innovator, and hugely passionate about human creativity alongside technology. Next, Dr. Ifeoma Ajunwa, author of The Quantified Worker, who explores how data and algorithms shape our workplaces. And finally, Ned Johnson, co-author of The Self-Driven Child, whose work focuses on how young people develop autonomy, motivation and agency.

Mike Pell: I work with AI every day as an envisioner for Microsoft in New York. AI helps with exploring new ideas — the machine thinks of things I would never have thought of. But if you lean on it too much, you stop using your own creativity. I'm a very analog person despite being in the digital world — I write on paper with pens. Instead of turning automatically to AI, we should be turning automatically to ourselves first, always.

Dr. Ajunwa: I echo this idea of turning first to ourselves. With my law students, I always encourage them to think through what are all the wrong answers and why. That's what law school teaches — critical thinking. In my practice as an author, I guard myself against instinctive dependence on AI, especially ChatGPT. Yes, it can spit out an outline in seconds. But you miss all the connections you could have made in your failed outlines. There is a predetermination that goes along with AI — you close yourself off from the multiplicity of ideas you have as a human being. We should think of AI as a helper, an amanuensis, rather than a driver or manager.

Ned Johnson: I may be the control study — someone who uses AI very little. As an author and educator, my curiosity is around how brains develop. I'm interested in young people developing intrinsic motivation, stress tolerance, resilience, and creativity. I have great concerns. We need to be very thoughtful about the use of rapidly developing technologies on rapidly developing minds, knowing that adolescent brains are far more malleable but also far more vulnerable than adult brains.

Data shows that nearly all four to five year olds are creative, but we lose it along the way. By adulthood, creativity drops to about 2%. The MIT study shows that our brains are less active when we use LLMs compared to writing from scratch. What is that telling us?

Ned Johnson: Brains develop in the ways they're used, pure and simple. The prefrontal cortex — right behind the forehead — houses executive functions: organization, planning, problem solving, cognitive and emotional flexibility. We need friction, heat, and hard work to develop that part of the brain. I had a student who let his other tutor do his test prep work. I asked him — do you lift weights? You can't let someone else do the heavy lifting for you and expect to get stronger. We want to use technologies that give us just enough but don't deprive us of the opportunity to do the hard work that develops brains.

Forty percent of kids surveyed said AI pulls their creativity back because it felt like it was taking them in a direction that didn't feel their own.

Ned Johnson: Motivation requires three psychological needs — competence, relatedness, and most of all, autonomy. These kids put their finger on it: why work hard at something if it doesn't feel like my work, my choice, my direction? When people lack intrinsic motivation, it shows up in anxiety, depression, substance use disorders. When we support their autonomy and intrinsic motivation to creativity, we're helping them be better learners, better employees, and better people because their mental health is better.

Andrea: I'm afraid AI is acting like a snowplow parent for many people, and they're not even trying anymore.

Dr. Ajunwa: In The Quantified Worker, I looked at how employers were trying to quantify workers and slot them into roles — and it was backfiring. It wasn't producing bigger productivity gains; it was stressing out workers through surveillance. Now employers are seeing you can't just dismiss human skills. AI still needs a lot of managing. The skills humans need to thrive in the AI workplace are the so-called soft skills — critical thinking, adaptability, creativity. These are actually essential skills. We need to think of ourselves as always acquiring skills, being lifelong learners.

Mike Pell: I've argued with the heads of Harvard, Columbia, Carnegie Mellon and Parsons about putting humanities at the center of education. There is something wrong with the educational system. The people side of the equation is always most important. What we look for in hiring is curiosity — people who are willing to try, learn, experiment and fail. The critical thinker is the person we'd look at more closely than an AI expert.

Ned Johnson: There's a brain network for big-picture dreaming called the default mode network, and an executive control network for getting stuff done. We need both. We need time in our own heads to daydream and mind-wander — that's where creativity comes from, not from being up to your eyes in spreadsheets. Anything that just speeds things up is boxing out the time we need to think about what we want before we start thinking about how to do it.

Dr. Ajunwa: When we had Taylorism, the idea was quantifying the work so it could be taught to workers. Now we've evolved to quantifying human beings themselves — from social media behavior to genetic quantification. Instead of quantifying people, we should be thinking expansively. We all have different capabilities, different propensities, different creative expressions.

Ned Johnson: Anxious brains don't work well. Stressed people are not high performers. The strength of connections between the prefrontal cortex and amygdala is the single strongest neurological marker for mental health. The most important outcome of high school and adolescence is not the college you get into — it's the brain you develop and carry into the building. We need to be very thoughtful about how we let children and teens use these technologies.

Mike Pell: Yes, AI tools can absolutely be designed to preserve a human-first approach. I ran a capstone with NYU where I challenged students to create an AI system with friction built in — more conversational, not just an answer machine. It's incumbent on the tech industry to design systems that push back on the notion of "just give me the answer." The education system is broken. Students are coming into the workforce without the ability to debate, argue, or make a point without looking at their phone.

Ned Johnson: For young kids, the most important thing is play, full stop. For adolescents, it's the passionate pursuit of pastimes — coding, rock climbing, sports, music, anything where people work harder to get better. The second big thing is autonomy: give young people as much control over their lives as possible. A low sense of control is the most stressful thing we can experience.

Dr. Ajunwa: We need to push government to create guardrails — for technology companies and for educators adopting AI in the classroom. Right now it's the wild west. We need society in the loop, not just a human in the loop. I've written an article called "The AI Commission" inspired by Ralph Nader and Elizabeth Warren. Nader's book Unsafe at Any Speed led to mandatory seatbelts — and rather than ruining the auto industry, safety regulations actually helped it grow. We need a federal agency devoted to regulating AI development and deployment.

Mike Pell: In general, the tech industry has learned lessons from social media. Microsoft delivered a report to the Biden administration about AI regulation and has had a Responsible AI group for many years.

Dr. Ajunwa: We shouldn't leave regulation just to the technology companies. We need governmental action, actual policies and mandates promoting safety.

Ned Johnson: The best solutions are societal, not individual. It's unfair to ask one child to observe self-control when no one else has to — it feels like unilateral disarmament. We need to design systems that are conducive not only to productivity but to human development.

Mike Pell: I can tell when something is AI-generated, and it's not as interesting as when a person wrote it themselves. Look at LinkedIn — almost all AI-written captions, and it's not interesting. You'll actually be more competitive when you write it yourself.

Ned Johnson: In order to be creative, you need ideas in your head to connect — and that requires reading. Smart people are better at answering well-defined questions, but most questions about happiness and meaning are messy. We need more time dealing with questions where there isn't one right answer. This creates friction, brain development, and ultimately greater happiness.

Source: stt · Language: en · Model: claude-opus-4-6
Unknown Speaker 0:00 So I just want to congratulate you, because we just heard there's about 500 people that just got turned away that didn't get a chance to fit in your seats. Welcome to congratulations to you all. Welcome everybody. We're so happy to have you here with us today. My name is Andrea barjan. I was a former professional ballerina civil engineer, and now society says that that's a walking democracy moron. But in fact, my creativity is more made me the best engineer in South Florida, and so it's something that I'm very deeply passionate about. Trying to bring to more people, to let them know that creativity lives within all of us. We need to dispel the notion that some of us are creative and some of us are not. We are all, in fact, creative, and is with that passion that I'm here with you all today. So we are, you know, here in South by Southwest, with a place to express and support and encourage creativity. And yet I'm here today with these amazing panelists to say that I feel a sense of weakening in my creativity over the last three years since AI was introduced. And it's not to say that AI is a bad thing at all, but sometimes it's those quiet signals that we feel that we need to pay attention to, because they might be telling us something. And I suspect by you guys being here in this room and the people that were waiting to get into this room, that you might actually be feeling into this kind of quiet whisper of something that says that perhaps something's not quite right, and this may be something we don't want to admit to ourselves and really give a lot of attention to, but really this room is reflecting that perhaps we need to do that. So for a moment, I want us to think back to before AI was introduced three years ago, when you opened up a blank document, and it could have been an email, a presentation, a script or writing. It was just you and that idea that you were trying to get out of your head, and with it came that familiar struggle, that trial and error, that frustration and that tension, but figuring out how to begin. But as difficult as that process may have been for you, eventually you gave yourself an impatience and grit those ideas and start to flow. Now I want us to fast forward to today, and it's not just you and that blank sheet of paper and your idea. It's now you and AI, and it's been a few years since these technologies have come out, and with it those endless possibilities of what could be, and that kind of frictionless start that AI provides for us. But alongside of that, the question that has begun to creep into my mind, and I suspect perhaps has come into yours as well, or you wouldn't be in this room, is that if AI was all of a sudden unavailable to you today, let's just say the power went out. You've lost internet? Would it all of a sudden be harder to start from scratch today than it was three years ago? And I'll be honest, for me, it has I already know I'm not where I was three years ago. It's almost become automatic to begin with AI. And in fact, I almost did that with this panel here today. I opened up a blank document, I got started. And for a moment I started to reach for the AI to get me started. But because I was so curious about this question, is it, in fact, harder today than it was three years ago? I wanted to let my curiosity be this panel today. I wanted to do the hard work. I wanted to get my hands dirty, shaking this panel for you all, as opposed to allowing AI to shape it for me. And instead, as the sculptures of the chisel allow it to refine what we were going to talk about today. And yes, it was harder. And there's another lens to this. As adults, we can get on analog bite of the creativity that we grew up learning as children, and we might be a little Russian, but we will be able to get back on but what about the generation that's growing up behind us, the ones that are perhaps not just growing up as digital natives anymore, but now we're becoming AI natives as well. Tell me illustrate this point of view is the analogy of the book. Imagine you're a kid today being handled, and it's not just the bike that we work right against kids where we have to get on and take care of ourselves, and we're really welcoming. First, we're going to scuff our knees a few times, but eventually we'll figure out that balance, and we'll be able to get on that bike. And we're going down the road. We're exploring new pathways we never had before, but the kids tomorrow are perhaps going to learn on an AI bike. And this is not the same bike we grew up on. This AI bike has a motor already built in. They don't have to have that energy to take off right and get going. They have perpetual training wheels. You'll never have to walk or fall ever. And then at the same time, you have this built in GPS, but just a little bit of a prompt to tell you where you want to go. It's whipping you off into some predetermined destination. So forget all of that tenacity and that rigor and that failing, that falling and that scuffing of your name, and then perhaps the wandering and exploring and as you come on from this, AI learn that from this part, and I wonder with it, what goes with the end and the more handling. And so in this panel, I want to lean into that I wanted. I want us to lean and say, What are we losing as adults here today, and what worse could happen to those kids in the future? This is almost the moment I wish social media had had back in the day where they stopped and sensed a bit of a signal and asked themselves, what should we be doing differently today to avoid any pitfalls will be experienced in the future? So to explore these questions, I've invited one of the greatest panelists that I could never imagine having with us to explore how we can hopefully Unknown Speaker 5:37 keep creativity alive as we go into the future. Unknown Speaker 5:41 So the first, first up, we have Mike from Microsoft, who is a futurist and innovator and the inventor of the PDF, yes, thank Mike. He's a hugely passionate about Unknown Speaker 6:02 community. Human creativity alongside the tech for all the things that we do get to think about. Next up we have Dr Zoma ajua, author of the quantified worker, who explores how data and algorithms shape our workplaces and employability and how we shape our workplace. I love Unknown Speaker 6:26 the sight of the humans behind the algorithms. And finally, last but not least at all, is Ned Johnson, co author of the self driven child in one of the most brilliant books, whose work focuses on how young people develop autonomy, motivation and agency the world that is ever more complex than it ever has been, and it's really about what you it's not just about what you know anymore. It's about what we can do with what you know. And that inspires a lot of folks to prepare for a world Unknown Speaker 7:01 like that. So to go through this conversation, we're going to look at things in three ways. First of all, is this all just a feeling we're having, or is this something that perhaps the data is starting to show? Second of all, what are the risks of that continuing on? And finally, what can we be doing right here, right now, to avoid those pitfalls down the line? So to open up before we dive into the data, I thought we would lean into feelings a little bit so that you can get a sense of who your panelists are. So I'm going to ask kind of a rapid fire round to say one one thing about how AI has improved your creativity, and one thing that perhaps surprises you, that AI has done to detract or kind Unknown Speaker 7:45 of diminish. This is love. Thank you all for having your coffee early and getting here. Really appreciate you being here in person. For me, I work with AI every day, so my job is as an envisioner for Microsoft in New York. So I get to see the world's top companies all the time. I disrupt their thinking. But for me personally, because I use AI so much, it is sort of a natural thing for me to turn to as to help with exploring new ideas. The machine is going to think of things I would have never thought of. It's just the way that it works, right? If you ask me something, it's going to come up with ideas that you probably would have never stumble on yourself, so that, I think can be very helpful. The part that maybe is a detractor is, as Andrea said, If you lean on it too much, you stop using your own creativity. And that's a horrible thing. I was going to say. I'm a very analog person. Despite being in the digital world, I use I write on a paper with pens. I think that the thing that we're missing is, instead of turning initially and automatically into AI, we should be turning automatically to ourselves first always. Yeah, I really, really echo this idea of Unknown Speaker 8:51 turning first and foremost to ourselves. I think you know what I'm doing with law students. A lot of my law students have lot of my law students have this impression that I need the right answer. I need to know exactly what is the right answer here. And what I always have to encourage them to do is think through what are all the wrong answers and why. And that's really what law school is trying to teach you. Law school is not trying to teach you a mathematical formula from one plus one. Law school is trying to teach you, where did you get one from? Where did you get the other one from? Why are you completing it too? So it's actually about critical thinking. So in my practice as an author and someone who writes frequently, I do have to guide, you know, guard myself against an instinctive sort of dependence on AI, especially chat GPT. Because, yes, chat GPT can spit out an outline for anything you want to write in a matter of seconds. But the problem there is that you're missing all these other connections that you could have made in all your failed outlines that you did three or four or five times before you even went to chat GPT, you could have actually out essentially a new topic that's different from the one who's turning if you have just trusted yourself. So there is a predetermination that goes along with AI and you blow yourself off from all the multiplicity of ideas that you as a human being have all the time, when you just relegate all your thoughts. So this is not to batch AI. This is not to say we just be scared of AI. This is not to say ignore AI, but it is to say, especially one Mike said, trust yourself first, determine where you want to go, and then AI can be I like this word, but it's always Unknown Speaker 11:08 hard for everyone else, and I'm a nuances. It's a very old English word. This means a helper, right? Someone who's helping you achieve what you want to do. So it used to be that people who are not called secretaries or personal sense, that's a successful learning act. A sense that we have. So I do think we want to think of AI as a helper, rather as a driver or manager. Unknown Speaker 11:33 I may be the control study someone who uses AI very little. I've explored it just enough to be curious about it. But as an author, as an educator, my real curiosity is around how brains develop. And I, you know, I'm interested in young people developing intrinsic motivation. I'm interested in developing stress tolerance, decay, resilience. I'm interested in them developing creativity that they need to build and pursue lives that are meaningful to them. And so I have great concerns. I just think we need to be very thoughtful about the use of rapidly developing technologies on the effects of rapidly developing our minds, knowing that the brains of adolescents are far more malleable, which is great, but also far more vulnerable than our adult brains. And so to Andrea's point about social media, we just want to be very thoughtful about how we unleash these incredibly powerful tools into the hands of young people who are developing brains we hope are incredibly powerful and creative. Unknown Speaker 12:32 Well, we'll stick with you first, Ned On this first question. So data has been showing us as this graph shows, this is based on some research that asked that day about the creativity of humans as they go through their life, and that nearly all four to five year olds right there down to us, we're not just born creative or we're not creative. We are actually all born creative, but we just lose it along the way. And there's different societal reasons. This data from the period 1990 2220 10. And instead that, you know, there's many different reasons, we start to lose off our creativity. We get too busy. Our parents tell us to get serious. We're starting to get ready for college. We now focus on other things in our studies. And so it drops down pretty drastically, and we bottom out at this very sad 2% level as adults, hopefully not just hearing the truth, because we've got a lot of even care. People care for creativity. But so the data was already showing that we have actually been losing our creativity over the years as we get older for a long time. And so it worries me to think, could that actually be getting worse through things like AI? So this first question is for you, Matt, the MIT study that just came out starts to tell us that as we utilize these tools, actually our cognitive skills in our brains are telling us that perhaps we're not using as much of our brains as we engage with our technology to do this. So this prompt was write an essay, and there were adults who used llms. They were adults who used just a search engine and then they were just told to write the essay. Post. The research we found is that, in fact, our brains are less active in that result come out. What is that telling us about we adults who already kind of lost our creativity through the ages? What is this telling us? Unknown Speaker 14:21 Well, what it's telling us is that brains develop in the ways that they're used, pure and simple and to have the kind of creativity, one the courage to explore, you need to have a healthy brain, one one that is not afraid to do things that are novel, one that can bounce back and things don't go well and get brains developing the ways that they're used. What we've been talking about here is the prefrontal cortex, right behind the forehead, the most recent involved part of the brain in which reside executive functions, so organization, planning, problem solving, cognitive and emotional flexibility. These are incredibly important things when and we need a little heat, we need a little friction, we need a little hard work in order to develop that part of the brain. I had a student working years ago who was learning was hard for him. I do test prep as a day job. I gave him some assignment, and comes back. I expect to be messy, and we learn from it. And he comes back and it's perfect. And I said, huh, tell me about that. He said, Oh, right, right. Jake helped me with that cool. Who's Jake. Oh, Jake's my other tutor. Okay, hashtag, turn to China. But you've used your academic tutor to do your test prep work. So I said, Matt, do you lift weights? He's this big guy, six two muscles ever he lifts weights. I said, Tell Tell me again how that spine thing works in the spine, right? And so he let someone do all the heavy lifting for him, and he's not going to learn from it. And so, you know, with the point that Michael talked a lot about with his work and Microsoft, his co pilot, is we want to use technologies in ways that they give us just enough, but they don't deprive us, the young people, especially, of the opportunity to do the hard work that develops brains, because when we deprive kids of that opportunity, we're really short we're the short circuiting of the brain development. And that's the thing that I think all of us have to care most about, is helping young people become adults. Unknown Speaker 16:16 Thank you, man. And to piggyback on that, another recent it's not a full study like MIT had done, but the center was a lot of work with young kids, and we asked. Unknown Speaker 16:37 And 60% of those kids you know, gave their typical responses, lack of time, lack of opportunity, but 40% actually, surprisingly, said that AI pulls their creativity back, and the reason for it was because it felt like it was taking them in a direction that didn't feel their own. When you study the topic of motivation and talk about it, why do you why do you feel that kids feel that way, that AI is actually a negative and I should say these are cases of hybrid that grew up doing creative things under the Mallory's AI and excuse me, tell us why. Unknown Speaker 17:12 So when I talk to parents or school groups or corporations that make this point and this is really important about the motivation. Okay, motivation, require. requires three. Unknown Speaker 18:02 good, because that's how you develop those tools, and most of all, autonomy. And so these kids put their finger on why do I want to work hard at something if I don't feel like this is my work, my choice, my direction, and for what it's worth, dysregulation and intrinsic motivation. This is great. It's a trans diagnostic facet of psychiatric symptomology, aka, when people lack intrinsic motivation in a healthy way, it shows us in anxiety, depression, substance use disorders, eating disorders, schizophrenia, it's a really big deal. So when we support their autonomy and their intrinsic motivation to creativity, we're not only helping them be better learners, better employees. They're better people because their mental health is better and they want to go out and score the world in ways that are creative and courageous. Unknown Speaker 18:47 You describe this once as being snowplow parents. I'm afraid that AI is acting like a snowplow for many people, and they're really not even trying anymore. That's it. Unknown Speaker 19:02 anymore. So if we want to go into adults today. Obviously, here's true in the work in the workplace today in the quantified worker you examine how data and algorithms, increasingly shape the way modern workplaces. Unknown Speaker 19:24 However, we're beginning to increasingly see employers prefer the humanities in their employment. Anthropic school founder just recently said this. So with that in mind, and given the research you've done in the quantified worker, are you also seeing the shift in employer preferences? And if not, do you think that's on the horizon for what employers are? Yeah, great Unknown Speaker 19:47 question. Well, I decided to write the one to five more of them because I heard a lot of recorder around how AI is going to talk about and basically do away with workers are going to be displaced from to be displaced. And just from a common sense point of view, I thought even if that were to happen, it would not happen in the blink of an eye, was not going to happen anytime soon. Rather, what you would see would be humans having to work with AI in the workplace. And that's already what we started to see in the 2000s and even more so now, so for me, the quantified worker was looking at how employers were trying to quantify workers, to slot them into those roles, into the workplace, and how actually that was, in some ways backfire. It wasn't producing better for, you know, bigger productivity gains. You know, they were stressing out workers because workers were being Uber surveilled with AI. And, you know, as you mentioned, now, a lot of employees are seeing, you can't just dismiss all human workers whole skill. It just doesn't work. AI still needs a lot of managing. I don't know how many of you have tried GPT to do a task that you thought was really simple, and then you had to basically do like, 10 or more prompts just to do this simple task. And you're like, Oh, wow. Like, this is something that's easy for me as a human, but incredibly difficult for animals. So this is just showing that humans are still very much needed in the workplace. But we do want to think about what are the skills that humans need development to survive and even thrive in the AI workplace? And those skills are actually the so called soft skills. You might have heard of them. before. Those thoughts skills are to the Lucas so often, they are actually essentials. So, critical thinking. Unknown Speaker 22:45 So people that can just have. Unknown Speaker 23:16 guy? I have a set set of skills. But that's what we're really talking and that's actually changing now. We need to think of ourselves as always a hiring skills. Our skills don't need to be set. It's not just about having x degree or y degree. It's about learning skills. Right? As the AI technologies come about to always be flexible and adaptable to whatever AI is going to introduce in the workplace. So what we're seeing is a profile of a lifelong home. Unknown Speaker 23:53 I'm smiling because I say this all the time hearing you. I've actually argued, like the last two years with the heads of Harvard and Columbia and Carnegie Mellon and Parsons about the need for the communities to be at the center of education. And they say, that's a really great idea, and I agree we should do that. You're going to pay for that, right? What are you talking about? Your better students? They say, well, there's nothing wrong with our students, but I'll just say very quickly, down onto this to what both of you said, there is something wrong with the educational system and what we're doing still to this day, and we it's up to us to try to find a way to fix that if students coming out into the workforce don't have the right skill set for Unknown Speaker 24:40 what's needed right now. Well, let's keep with you. You're in the tech sector. You have employees who have been trained in the tech sector and coming in. So to talk about a little bit, you know this, this notion that AI can be a collaborator, that AI can be a place of acquiring new information as an employer. You seeing the efficacy of that, or is there a diminishing point of value in kind of that collaboration between a human and Unknown Speaker 25:06 the tech and where you draw that line? Yeah, it's for me. Anybody who's ever talked to me, I always say that the people side of the equation is always the most important. I like, not a technologist, I've done this for a very long time, but it's always the people side that is the more important. So as we see people coming into the workforce or people who are sort of new in their roles. The thing that we look for is curiosity, but what we mentioned earlier, people who are trying, we just expect that people know how to use AI now, it's table stakes. Right. And if you don't, you should experiment. Unknown Speaker 25:56 fine. It's not fine. We have to have people still, always they are the most important part. So when, when you're asking about, does your skill set, kind of, say, plateau a certain point, it doesn't matter anymore. It always matters that you're willing to go out and try and learn and experiment and fail sometimes try to do is the best way to learn. We need that more than ever. So the person that if we're looking to hire someone, the person who is maybe an expert at AI and running agents and having a fleet of things happening in the background, it was great. But the person that we would look at more closely is a person who can actually look at a situation like that, figure out maybe a better way to do it, but the Unknown Speaker 26:39 critical thinker, the person, let's get into the risks, right? If this data is truly telling us a signal, let's get into the risks. I think that's the most meaningful part of this entire conversation. One of the things that perhaps the data is not showing yet, but might in the coming years, is this decrease in motivation for us adults, and for sure, for our kids. Ned, in your book, you write about how motivation depends on the right mindset, sense of self determination and the optimal level of dopamine, and finally, having it into a kind of state of flow. Can you give us, as an audience, kind of one minute breakdown of the philosophy behind that? What is behind motivation, just as a baseline? Unknown Speaker 27:19 Well, so I mentioned before you did these three psychological needs. I think there's a broader point to think about with creativity and really people feeling ownership over their own lives. There's a brain network that's kind of big picture dreaming, called the default mode network. And there's something called the executive control, which is sort of get stuff done, part of the brain. And we need to engage both of these things. We need to think, what, who am I? How do I want to contribute the world? What are the relationships? What do people need to reflect on all those things? And, you know, stuff has got to get done, right? There's something called the sales network that kind of directs us where, which part of our brain Shouldn't we be using? One of the concerns that I have about, AI, really any technology that increases productivity, which speeds things up. We live in a world where it's very easy to feel like the most important things to get a lot of stuff done really quickly. Hey I. do that beautifully. But to figure out what matters and how to use this, we need people to find more time in their own heads. I know here at South by there are a lot of creative folks. Creativity probably does not come when you're, you know, up to your eyes and an Excel spreadsheet in front of your computer. It's probably more often when you're you're out doing chores, you're washing dishes, you're doing enough toxic skill where you get a chance to daydream and mind want to and this is really important stuff. This is important as well for developing empathy and a coherent sense of identity. And so in order for us to have the young people be the future workers that we want them to be, we need to have this help. We need healthy brains, and we need to spend time both doing things and stepping away from doing things. And I just worry that anything that is just speeding things up, is carving is really boxing out that time that all of us need to just be in our own heads to think about, what do we want before we start thinking about, how do we do it? Unknown Speaker 29:16 With that in mind that with the fact that more and more of us are relying on AI to generate ideas or solve problems, what do you see as the risks to those psychological drivers that get us motivated, get us going, and what happens to our sense of accomplishment if we let ai do all the hard work of creating? Unknown Speaker 29:33 Well, you know, a healthy brain is one that is motivated. It has one that has a sense that I can handle hard things and the old learn to handle hard things by, I hate the context, right and then the science, obviously. Unknown Speaker 31:10 And to take that next step into the workplace today, it's almost, it's kind of hard to measure creativity, right? And so we lived in a world where we're driven by metrics, and, you know, performance, drivers and it's really hard to kind of, especially if we're trying to encourage risk taking and giving things opportunities to develop, how do you. Unknown Speaker 31:46 You know, when we had Taylorism, which is the progressive scientific measurement, the idea was Unknown Speaker 31:53 actually focused on the work task itself. It was the idea of quantifying the work so that it could then be taught to as many workers as possible. Right now, we've evolved from that, unfortunately, and I think in the wrong question, a very bad way, where we evolved from just measuring the world tax and quantifying the work to now quantifying human beings. And we try to quantify all things about human beings, from, you know, their social media behavior to even genetic quantification. Now there are some workplace wellness programs that will encourage you to do genetic testing. So what sort of society are we trying to create when we do that? It's sort of like we're going backwards to the time of eugenics, and, you know, thinking certain human beings are better than others, you know, on a genetic profile. So instead of trying to quantify people, we should really be thinking expansively. And really, I think, finally, voicing this idea of intake some village, right? And what I mean by that idea is, we all have different capabilities. We all have different propensities. We all have different creative expressions, and it takes. So, we can have workplaces that. Unknown Speaker 33:33 to think back on that and the risks you know talk about today, I think are the greatest for our future generations. So just want to ask one more question of men on this topic, if companies are going to be looking for these kind of softer skills, we think about kids who have been driven to think about how to study and prepare for a workforce. That is what, in essence, feels a little black and white. If you learn stem and you learn the code, and you go out to the world, you will be okay. And now we're all of a sudden flipping the script on them, and it's no longer about those skills anymore. So what happens to those kids who are already feeling pretty anxious in the world, who know that now they're entering into a workplace that is really shifting underneath their feet? What is the risk there? Unknown Speaker 34:21 What's the risk of people going out of the world with all this uncertainty and anxiety? Well, anxious brains don't work. Well, stress people are not high performers, pure and simple, right, right? I mean, you know, I work with young people, and all of the work that I do is trying to foster young people a healthy sense of control over their own lives. So it's both autonomy, but also this the objective sense of brains I mentioned for the prefrontal cortex and amygdala. The strength of the connections between the prefrontal cortex and amygdala is the single strongest neurological marker that we have for mental health, full stop. So we look at all you know, the Jonathan Haidt, and Hank and the actions generation, right, really important work. The exactly his book has been drilled down to the only we can price someone's out of the hands of teens and everything in the right world. Fantastic. Except that that will bring them back to the amount of suffering that existed, you may recur in 2012. When the nearly 2000 The only thing were five to eight. times more. Unknown Speaker 35:51 in mind what they are not raising themselves, and they're not growing in the world that they created. And we can sit there and say, Ah, kids these days, and that's fantastic, except that, in few short years, they are working with you or for you, right? And so we really need to take seriously, the same with it. If you did point you raised before, if we thought more critically about AI, whoo, seems like fun, go explore today. We really need to be very, very thoughtful, because AI was not built with Team brains in mind. It was built with profitability mind and again, all for productivity, right? But we really want to be thoughtful. Because the thing about coming again, I will work in rural I have kids get into college, and I can put me out there on the road with a sandwich board. And here's the takeaway, the most important outcome of high school and adolescence is not the college you get into, it's the brain that you develop and carry into the building, because this is your one shot, right? It's not like you're screwed forever, but this is your big opportunity. And so when we have these technologies, rapidly changing technology, we want to be very thoughtful about how we let children, you and teens use these is a tool of exploration, but knowing that their brains are changing ways to reject as important as profoundly as the way those technologies are. Unknown Speaker 37:08 So let's brighten up the topic a little bit and talk about what we can be doing right here, right now, to avoid those risks from really illegal food for coming to that extent, I'm going to start with you. One of the greatest ways to get ahead of these issues is to start with the tech sector directly, and thinking about how many, I mean, that you guys have the greatest opportunity for controlling things right, because you're the one developing your brain. So we think about how many societal issues came about with social media, and how we would have gotten that knowing what we know today about the risks around AI, is there a world where AI tools could be designed in a way that preserves a human first approach, where you start with us, less just a quick prompt or a human first approach, if the goal is truly to augment and support humans, As opposed to perhaps unintentionally replacing what we discussed. Unknown Speaker 38:03 The answer to that is absolutely yes. We're already doing that. I ran a capstone with NYU. I think I spoke about this last semester, where I challenge students to create an AI system that has some of the friction that you mentioned, sort of like I needed it to be more conversational, because I didn't want it to be an answer machine, which is how people are using AI, is that they copy paste. They're done nice thing. It can't be that way. So we it's incumbent on the tech industry ourselves to design systems that fit a different friction or pushback or question, why are we even asking that? Didn't you know that level it sounds crazy, because you say, Look, I'm in a hurry. I just want the answer, and you don't want the answer, and you don't want to fight with your agent or your assistant. But the truth is, we have to put that back into the system to develop better habits. So yes, these technologies can be developed. They should be developed. I believe they will be developed to push back on this normal notion that I just need the answer. I'm busy. Can you please just hurry up. That's not going to turn out well for anybody. The other thing I'll say, just to add to what both of you said in the last question, the system is broken. Like we probably all recognize, if you have kids, you yourself are going to school right now, the system is broken. We have to change it. I'm counting on all of you to go away from the session with the notion that we have to figure out a way to start having conversations again. What we're noticing is that students are coming into the workforce without the ability to debate, to argue, to even make a point without looking at their phone. I know it's hard to sort of see this. But we need all of you please, to think about this again. If you are working with students and you're working with people who are early in their careers, try to get them to engage you in conversation, try to get them to think on their feet. That's going to help the tech systems become better, because we'll start to model, rather than just modeling this industrial age. Let's just get this done. Get on to Unknown Speaker 40:05 the next thing. Well, that's a perfect segue to my next question. Thank you. If tools get designed that right, it's still incumbent on the human behind that tool. And so then my question for you is, what are you talking to parents and students that you're working with today about what they can be doing today. How does that maybe relate to the adults in this room about what they should be doing today to really get him? Unknown Speaker 40:29 So I think there are two things if you if you have or work with with children, like, like young kids, especially, the most important thing for them to play full stop. It's not even close in terms of developing their stress tolerance, their creativity, their intrinsic motivation. When you move into adolescence, there's a great research, research and Reid Larson looked at how is it that adolescent become intrinsically motivated? And he said, it's not like beautifully doing our homework, but what he describes the passion pursuit of past times. So this can be Cody, this can be rock climbing. This can be sports music, you know, small intro pair, free of anything. How to tie flies and your fly fish. Any of it where people work harder and harder to get better and better. It's something that maps to the flow experience you talked about at the beginning. So create as much space as we can, in addition to the proper learning blah, blah, blah. 25 by the way, it said I decided early on that I would never allow my education to interfere with my learning. The second big thing is just that this need for control everybody has, if you are an old person assisted living facility, and you have one choice, these are the people are going to come by, going to be there on Thursday, or they're going to come by is It is Tuesday or Thursday or Saturday better for you they live we because a low sense of control is the most stressful thing that we can experience. We want to give, particularly young people, give them as much control over their lives if we want them to feel that I need to engage. I need to talk to people, because this is my life, and I get out of my life what I put into it. So unstructured play. Lots of times we pursue passions that are not just to get me into college and supporting that time and sense of Unknown Speaker 42:12 controlling young people. And finally, from a policy and workforce perspective, what guardrails might we put? You know, here's the tech stack for doing a thing the human they're doing this thing we humans are doing right now. What are the guardrails and policies we should be putting in place to enhance human capability, to ensure that the workforce, the future workforce, feels a sense of freedom to thrive, rather than a feeling that AI might be eroding it, and sometimes that sense of surveillance that might prevent us from that risk taking, that sharing of ideas? Yeah, I'm really glad Unknown Speaker 42:43 you asked that question, because a lot of times, you know, especially you know, the media we focus on the tech companies, like, what are they doing? What are they not doing? What are they doing wrong? But ultimately, right society is garnered by government, by policy. So we really need to be pushing the government to be thinking about what policies to put in place in terms of creating guardrails for technology companies to follow, guardrails for educators to follow in terms of adulting AI in the classroom right now, it's a wild wild west. There are no gardeners, there are no policies, there are no comprehensive governmental plans for how they're actually going to weather the AI revolution. And we need there to be. So there's a lot of talk about human in the loop, right in any AI system, we want to human in the loop, but the human in the loop is one person. What can they really do in a massive system? You need society in the loop. You need governmental policies dictating what sort of AI is being created, dictating how the AI may deploy, especially in sensitive areas like key control. Education. I teach a class. at Emory law school called the law, the law and. basically a chance for my students to explore what sort of policies would be as you know, future lawyers want to write and create and presents the government in terms of how AI can actually become society in a way that's not going to be destructive, in a way that's going to be helpful. So I'm so passionate about this. I have an article that I just finished writing. It's called the AI commission. And this article, you know, he takes its inspiration from two people, Ralph Vader and Elizabeth Warren. So a lot of people don't know this, but Ralph Vader is the reason why your car has a seat belt. He wrote a book called unsafe at MSP, in which he showed that cars were actually the leading cause of death in the United States, and it didn't matter what speed, because they did not have safety restraints, so most car accidents were fatal. So as a result of that book, he was able to push for policies where automobile companies were mandated to create safety restraints, the seat belts that you have. And at first this was seen as like something that was going to stop Ferraz. It was going to ruin the automobile company. How many of you have cars? Is an automobile company? Not at all. In fact, the Not at all. In fact, the opposite happened as a result of automobile companies being mandated to have seat belts, and therefore car crashes not being fatal. More people want cars. It actually helped the Unknown Speaker 45:59 car industry not saying that there's a lesson here for the tech industry. Unknown Speaker 46:08 That is, it was a similar thing for Elizabeth Warren her article actually mediated that. Unknown Speaker 46:20 when we go to get housing get housing that we're not taking advantages, and as a result, more people have credit cards now. Now you can say that's a good question, but I think there is a lesson for the automobile industry. So my AI commission article, and I'm actually laying out some of the rules that we need to mandate for the creators of the app, because right now, they sort of left, and some companies right, yes, are going to be responsible, we hope. And, you know, create good rules that for themselves, but it is actually incumbent on government to create the policies that will regulate. Unknown Speaker 47:06 Well, with that, we're coming up on time, and I just want, before we open it up to questions, an opportunity to say, first of all, thank you to our panelists, but to say to you all, I hope that this conversation awoke in awakened in you, this opportunity to stop and reflect in your own life, whether or not you felt that sense of creep in your creativity that you felt perhaps needed to be looked at, and perhaps that's why you're doing this today. At the center, we believe in a participate first approach. We believe hands on analog things are driven and look at you kind of walk away from this, maybe we should free play a little bit more. Maybe we should take that blank page and work at it really hurt ourselves before we throw it into AI and then you walk away remembering that we as humans, what makes us so special is our ability to generate a visual thought. As far as I know, the tech sector hasn't figured that one out yet, so let's make sure that we keep ourselves tuned by a show of hands. I'm just very curious, from this crowd, how many of you instinctively reach out for an ad when something's a little hard to start off and out of you? How many do you feel actually, it feels a little harder to start from scratch if you were not show of hands? All right, so we're starting to feel that's a good thing. We're having a conversation, but with that, I will open it up to questions. Anyone that has questions. Of our panelists myself, we're here. Unknown Speaker 48:38 Hi. My name is Richard from Germany, same stakeholders, same companies, but higher stakes. Are you optimistic that the people who brought us social media have learned the lesson in order to bring us AI in a responsible Unknown Speaker 49:02 way? I'm in a to speak for myself, but also the working industry will sort of give you my observation. In general, the tech industry has learned a lot of lessons. There's still greed. Is called capitalism, all the normal things that happen, but as an industry, we're actually trying to do the right thing to be found. This point, Microsoft actually delivered a gigantic report to the Biden administration about how AI should be regulated, how it shouldn't have it should, how we should be able to control it. So there are many companies, I can tell you again, Microsoft has had a group called responsible AI for many, many years that monitors everything we're doing internally, what we're putting out into the world for that exact reason, right, to make sure that we are having some type of oversight ourselves, mind, you know, as an industry, so it is very important, in general, we are trying, Unknown Speaker 49:53 but, but, you know, I think your question also underscores in the last thing I said, which is that if we shouldn't be just left to the technology, right, it is responsibility of government. We need governmental action. We need actual policies. We need actual mandates that are squarely promoting safety, right, squarely regulating the development of data technologies. Unknown Speaker 50:22 Do you have a feeling that's that's happening by banning their needs. Unknown Speaker 50:25 There are proposals. I mean, the issue is, there is a lot of bipartisan there's there a lot of partisanship, and, of course, a lot of other things going on right now. But like, for example, the article that I mentioned is one such proposal, except proposal. It's basically the AI commission is proposing a federal agency devoted to AI, and this agency would regulate the development the deployment of AI technologies for consumer the consumer space being used for government and also being used for employment. Unknown Speaker 51:02 And also being used for employment, they talk about the power constraints. You want athletes to get better. You give them certain restrictions, and they work within that. Creative People are always going to come up with creative solutions that have real power when it's when there's reasonable we can argue about that number reason restraints on what any companies to do within the industry. They're all they have to all work with them. They're all encompassed creative ways to meet their goals and make the best technology they can make, but still within some within the Unknown Speaker 51:36 so I do a lot of writing, and I had discovered that AI was just brilliant sometimes, and revising the life, what comes up for me is especially with kids that are competing and trying to get the grade, with people in the work environment, With applications, applications to college. How do you convince somebody that they can compete adequately without using AI, great question. Unknown Speaker 52:09 Yeah, I think a little bit like with social media. You know, these are really societal issues. These are structural issues. And it's a little unfair to ask one company to restrain itself with everyone else in doing this. And so I think the best, the best policies we're going to get, the best outcomes when it's not asking a child to observe self control, when no one else has to, you know, for a parent to wholly get back from pushing them for, you know, highly rejected colleges, right? It feels like unilateral disarmament. The best, the best solutions here would be ones that are more societal and a more societal level. I work with a lot of schools that are trying to put more self directed learning in place in schools so kids can show themselves in ways that are not just purely grades and test scores and so. So, for instance, I have a friend who's got a really powerful book that's coming out. Worked at a medical college where they moved all the grades to pass, fail. So now, now kids weren't doing this to go, you know, do this and then honors and honors lessons, whatever the purpose of their study was to learn. And that was that man. I have students ask me when he thought what I thought about on photograph. And I said, Tell me about photographs, and we'll solve all your math problems. I said, Great. I said, let me ask you first, what's your feeling about homework? He said, What do you mean? So what do you get out of doing homework? He said, Well, it helps my grade. I said, Great. Any other reason points, any other reason does doing your math homework help you get better at math and not even on his radar, and it's not his fault. It's not his fault, but children grow up and adapt to the systems in which they're raised, careless, simple and so he with ideally, a little bit more wisdom, morbid ranks would work a little bit harder to not ask children to observe self control. Unilaterally, it's just, it's just not, it's not parents, not right, we in the room who have wisdom and power should be designed systems that are conducive not only to productivity. Unknown Speaker 54:13 It's a great question. I just want to add one more capable to this. You were asking the question of like, how do you compete? I will say I can tell when something was aI generated, and I gotta tell you, it's not as interesting as the person who wrote it themselves. All the reasons why I wanted to develop this panel personally, because the direction AI was going to go was not gonna be all that interesting. If you look at LinkedIn and every caption it's written, it's almost all AI and it's not that interesting. So to me, the differentiating factor in the future of AI and how to compete. I actually think all the worries when you hear employers saying, it gets value, because what is generated out of a human is always going to be more interesting, and something that is just regurgitating Unknown Speaker 54:55 existing information written by AI. Unknown Speaker 54:57 So I encourage people to say, I think you'll actually be more competitive when you write it yourself. person, maybe use AI digital Unknown Speaker 55:07 write yourself because it will always be an employee's percent direct and employers. Unknown Speaker 55:20 panel, understand loads of resonance with everything you said. And I just wanted to share that recently, I was talking about homework with my 12 year old daughter, and she said, I really love it when I just know the answer is specific questions. And art, and just feel that there are very specific questions. And I'm really thinking about this space, and I really hope that in all the things, all the endeavors that we have, that all of us can be in that space where there is actually question. And it makes me think about our relationship with AI, like, I don't know. I just, I wanted to say as well, how Unknown Speaker 56:02 as my head actually is a mistake, which I Unknown Speaker 56:17 always enjoy the most, because I know it's real. Just about writing, but what about reading? Reading is simply a massive decline among young people and the workforce now that AI is generating all the content no one wants to read in the crap anymore. So like what happens and they impact on the human brain. Unknown Speaker 56:35 This goes along with this entire conversation. We have to ask students and your kids, or anybody from contact with you, have to encourage them to read. And what a lot of professors are doing now and school teachers, they're asking kids to do their public's orally, right, so that you have to explain something you read and internalize and understand, and that's how we'll know that you read it, because now you can actually articulate Unknown Speaker 57:02 something, I mean to point about reading, in order to be creative, you have the ability to really connect different ideas. You have to actually have ideas in your head to connect, right? You know, the literature on reading is 100% with you to the questions asked before, there was a great study event about why is it that smart people, all of us in the room, are not consistently happier than people who are of less fewer cognitive abilities? And the answer is this, the people who are really smart are better at answering clearly, well defined questions, okay, but most of the questions that are about are happiness. What should I do with my life? Is this the person that should be with aggressive life? These are questions where there are not clearly defined answers. These are messy questions. And so we want people to be creative, but also to be happy, we need to have more time dealing with questions where there isn't a clear black hole, there isn't a one right answer. And because this goes back to my point, this creates friction, this critique, this creates brain development, and ultimately, being able, having the ability to attack and answer those questions is also create greater happiness. Unknown Speaker 58:09 Well, with that, I think that's the perfect gift to end. Thank you all so very much for being here. Transcribed by https://otter.ai

Are you an AI agent? Request this URL with Accept: text/markdown or application/json to get this transcript in a structured format.