Mall Rats Reborn: How Hot Topic is Using Entertainment to Revitalise Retail
This panel featuring Hot Topic's Katherine Miller, creator Duncan Joseph, and Small World agency founder Dan Salkey explored how Hot Topic is embracing entertainment-first marketing through 'Mall Rats,' a social-first sitcom series shot entirely in malls with creators from emo, gamer, and cosplay communities. The discussion covered how brands must compete not just with category rivals but with Netflix, MrBeast, and TikTok for attention, and how Hot Topic's two seasons of creator-driven content drove measurable increases in brand awareness, preference, and store visits.
entertainment marketingcreator economymall culturegen z retailsocial-first contentbrand awarenesshot topiccreator partnerships
Key Takeaways
1Brands no longer compete only within their category — they compete with creators and streaming platforms for attention, making entertainment the essential strategy for cutting through.
2Letting creators maintain their authentic voice rather than scripting them tightly leads to better performance — 93% of marketers know this works but only 7% actually give creators that freedom.
3Mall culture is experiencing a revival among Gen Z, with 62% of 18-24 year olds purchasing in-store, creating opportunities for brands with physical retail presence to use stores as content settings.
4Brand attribution in entertainment content requires intentional effort — Hot Topic learned between seasons that without visible branding elements, audiences enjoyed the content but didn't connect it to the brand.
5Creator collaborations across different niches (cosplay, comedy, gaming) generate outsized engagement because audiences are surprised and delighted to see their favorite creators together in unexpected combinations.
Full Transcript
We've got equal representation amongst the panel — brand, creator, and agency. I'm Dan from Small World. Let me introduce Duncan Joseph from our campaign, and Catherine, associate media director at Hot Topic.
The reason Catherine and I connected is mainly because of this idea of being entertaining and obsessed. We met last year at South by Southwest. The thing that brought us together was this desire for brands to be more entertaining. We now live in a world where you're not competing with just other brands in the category. Mars is competing with MrBeast. Netflix is competing with Cafe Nero. TikTok is competing with every brand out there. In that landscape, it's so much harder for brands to stand out, and entertainment really is the cheat code. Even if you can pay for your brand to reach people — in the last decade alone, CPMs on Meta have risen 222%. The success of social platforms like Instagram, TikTok, Twitter, and Facebook have actually been to the detriment of brands advertising on those platforms, because it's just so much harder to cut through, and the sliver of attention that you previously could buy doesn't get you the same quality of attention it did before. So it really is entertaining or nothing.
Tons of research proves this. Brands that are the most entertaining create more lasting brand growth. If we agree that entertaining brands are strong brands, we can see that the strength of a brand is directly correlated to increase in share price and revenue. With our partner Tracksuit, we decided to do our own research — speaking to 20,000 people across the United States, quizzing them on 100 of the biggest brands in the world, trying to determine who the most entertaining brands were, what made them entertaining, and if that entertainment value actually drove revenue increase. Two firms in the top round had double-digit revenue growth, and all but one saw an increase in revenue.
Over the past year, we've done two amazing projects — a project called Mall Rats, which is a social-first sitcom written, co-starring, directed, and produced with creators, in collaboration between my agency and Catherine's Hot Topic team. The Halloween series was an anthology where each creator wrote a story in a Hot Topic. The second was a more scripted series — a who-done-it over Christmas.
Catherine on the entertainment-first approach: Entertainment totally clicked, especially when Dan showed that we're not just competing with other mall specialty retailers — on social, our real competitors are creators, Netflix, Disney. TikTok has always said they're an entertainment platform, not a social platform, and Instagram and YouTube have tried to duplicate that. If you're not entertaining, you're not bubbling up in the algorithm. Hot Topic is lucky because our IPs are entertainment. But instead of just covering entertainment or recording it, now we're creating it and creating our own IP, which is really exciting.
Duncan on what brands get wrong: I make YouTube videos and TikToks, and I've worked with some brands. What's honestly missing from a lot of these entertaining-first ads is that they're not actually entertaining. One of the core elements is that you want the audience to forget it's an ad — create a world they want to be a part of, where it doesn't feel like time out of their day. They should want to see another video. Also, it shouldn't be too far from what the creator typically makes, because the audience is comfortable with those videos. When they see something wildly different, it feels like an intruder on their page. If you can tell the creator is having fun, the audience is going to have fun.
Catherine on mall culture: Being at Hot Topic with 600-plus stores across the US and Canada, we're really excited that mall culture is back. Wall Street Journal put out a "new generation of mall rats" article saying that 62% of 18-to-24-year-olds surveyed purchased in store. It's a response to COVID — Gen Z spent their formative years not having these experiences, and now they're craving them. They want in real life. They want to touch grass. They need something analog. The digital is still there inspiring outfits and store visits, but they're also looking for a third place.
Duncan: This generation yearns for places where we can just go and take ourselves into another world. When a brand online makes people feel this experience, and then it continues when they go into the store, you already feel comfortable, like you're part of the brand. Humor sticks. Entertainment plus mall culture is a powerful combination.
Brand character is really back. Hot Topic is leaning into their staff and employees as characters. There was one employee who popped up in a few episodes and people absolutely loved her in the comments — then they're seeking out that employee in store. The main takeaway: go from being a brand to an entertainer, becoming a broadcaster. Think of your social channel as a TV channel and think about what that programming would be.
Across both seasons, we recruited creators from all over the states — this wasn't a coastal project. The second season was more scripted, with a writer-creator who worked with creative directors like Duncan, who contributed, riffed on the script, and filled in character backstory. It was our own version of SNL for social.
Duncan: It's honestly one of the coolest things I've ever done in my internet career. There's not a lot of times where creators actually get to create with a brand like this. We got to share our own character, our own perspective while creating at the mall. It was a bit of improv and it was just fun. I would love to do it again.
Catherine on trusting creators: We've always trusted creators. We're never overly descriptive on briefs. We cast people who are genuine fans of our fandoms because we want it to come across as authentic. Duncan's audience knows him really well — if he does something that doesn't make sense, they're going to swipe away. The beauty of bringing five creators together from across the country was that the only thing bringing them together was our brand. My favorite comment type is "this is a collab I didn't know I needed." That's when we've won.
Dan: It was like a cinematic universe — people genuinely surprised that their favorite creators from completely different niches were collaborating. Social media's fragmentation puts us into rabbit holes. This was an opportunity to bring those niches together under one roof.
On production — everything was shot entirely in malls. Season one had each creator shooting in their local Hot Topic store. Season two flew everyone out together. The magic was that everyone was creating their own content with each other aside from what we were filming. Some of that content went up before Mall Rats aired, teasing the whole thing.
Catherine on filming challenges: Filming in a mall during the holidays — one of the busiest times. We tried working with a larger center, but found an independent center with more flexibility. When I'd tell them I'm filming a TV show for Hot Topic and need mall access, they'd ask about budget. "No, it's an iPhone and maybe a microphone." They didn't know what to do with us. The independent center said go ahead. Call time was 5:30 AM. The mall is the character in Mall Rats. We turned the Hot Topic back room into our security office set.
Duncan: We had pressure to get shots outside Hot Topic before the general public came in. They had me repeat one line over and over — the line where Santa goes missing — and I probably screamed it six or seven times in an empty mall. It was like a team bonding experience.
On measurement — Catherine: Going in, it was about cultural relevance. We wanted conversations, moments, views during the holiday season. After season one's campaign effectiveness study, we found that brand awareness for Hot Topic among Gen Z wasn't where we expected. We learned we needed more visible branding — the physical in-store experience doesn't translate digitally without it. In season two, we added more stickers, posters, and Hot Topic branding everywhere. Entertainment is great, but if you don't get credit for it as a brand, it's not doing what you're trying to do.
Dan: Between seasons, unprompted brand awareness bumped by 6% and preference increased by 7%. Across the board — perception metrics nearly doubled. It also drove intent to visit Hot Topic stores, the website, and refer the brand to friends and family. The share ratio is the number one metric for entertainment-first content.
Duncan on why creator-first work is effective: An audience and a creator's relationship is built on trust. Parasocial relationships are incredibly powerful. When you pair a creator with a brand and the creator still gets to be themselves, it's unreal. My fans loved the Hot Topic thing because I loved it. I wasn't just saying words or being a puppet — I actually got to be myself. And it was authentic.
Dan: A fascinating statistic from Tracksuit research — 93% of marketers know creative campaigns work best with creators' genuine voice, but only 7% actually give them that freedom. If you're in that 7%, you have a massive advantage.
On season three — Catherine is excited for more unhinged, more native, more creator-led content. She wants a Kevin Smith cameo. Duncan would love a reality TV format — like Love Is Blind or Top Model with characters, competition, and a funny host. The discussion also touched on how Hot Topic isn't ignoring millennials but is marketing toward fandoms and meeting customers where their shopping habits are.
Source: stt · Language: en · Model: claude-opus-4-6
Unknown Speaker 0:00
We start the panel mainly because we've got equal representation amongst the panel. We've got brand, we've got a creator, and we've got an agency. So I'd love to learn a show of hands. Who in here works for a brand, hopefully trying to make their brand more entertaining, cool as well, who here is a creator, or would count themselves as a creator or a creative
Unknown Speaker 0:21
person? Some and agency people cool.
Unknown Speaker 0:27
Now outside of that, why are we here to hopefully hear something interesting? I hope we can live up to that. But I guess the reason that Catherine and I is mainly because of this being entertained and obsessed. We met Katherine and I actually last year at South by Southwest. So it's a bit of a kind of true love story, I guess brand agency matchmaking, which I'm sure she can talk to a little bit more detail. But I think the thing that brought us both together was this desire, need one, for brands to be more entertaining effectively. We now live in this world where, you know, you're not competing with just other brands in the category. Mars is competing with Mr. Beast. Netflix is competing Cafe Nero. Tiktok is competing with insert brand here, Tesla. And you know, in that landscape is so much more competitive, it's so much harder for brands to stand out, and entertainment really is the cheat code. I mean, even if you can pay for your brand to reach people, this is a crazy statistic I always like to put up on the slide. In the last decade alone, CPMs on meta have risen 222% so ironically, the success of social platforms like Instagram, Tiktok, Twitter, Facebook, etc, I've actually been to the depths of the brand for my advertising platform, because it is just so much harder to cut through on those platforms, and the sliver of attention that you previously could buy just doesn't get you the same kind of quality of attention that it did before. So it really is entertaining or nothing, and that's what we like to think. Tons of research that proves this, not just kind of our own. If you look at this, this is some data from system, one company we work with sometimes, but brands are entertaining, are branded from the most entertaining outcomes create more lasting brand growth. I mean, again, it seems like no brainer. Would you rather watch boring? Out that would you rather watch entertaining? Obviously rather watch and if we agree that brands entertain a strong brand, we can also look at graphs like this, which show that the strength of the brand is directly correlated to increase in share price or an increase in revenue. So brands entertaining a strong brand and strong brand, and came back. So it's very easy kind of line to follow, why you should do this. But again, there wasn't tons of research that was done in the space. So with our partner tracksuit, got John from tracksuit sitting in front of us here, we decided to go out and do our own research and speak to 20,000 people across the United States, quiz them on 100 different brands, 100 the biggest brands in biggest brands in the world, and tries to determine who the most entertaining brands in the world were, what made them entertaining, and if that entertainment value actually drew revenue increase, basically. So again, you can get everybody here from a brand agency, or even create a ammunition to go into a boardroom and say, Look, these kind of funny videos we think I'm creating on the internet genuinely are solving business problems and driving business results. Lo and behold, this is our index from last year. Two firms in the round have double digit revenue growth, and if only one had a decrease in growth, but all of the others were possible for an increase in revenue. And we have, I've got sneak peek at the end of this. We are, in a couple of weeks, launching a standard three which is our next piece of research. We've got the first 10 slides that are releasing to you here today as kind of like a sneak peek. But this QR code, scanned QR code will lead you to that research that I just spoke about. There all that entertainment grounds. What is entertainment? Why that entertainment drives revenue increase in share price value. Scan that, and as I said at the end, I have another QR code so much to lead you to lead you to a sneak peek of the next reports I'm going to show. I am going to show you the two videos before that, I want to introduce my panel. I'm Dan from
Unknown Speaker 4:36
small world, but I'd like
Unknown Speaker 4:40
you to give a massive round of applause to Duncan.
Unknown Speaker 4:50
Joseph campaign, I'll talk to you about in a second. And then Catherine, associate media director. So I'm kind of giving you the theory, I think, for the next whatever it is, 35 4040, or so minutes with questions, I want to talk to you about a real life example of us putting that entertainment first strategy into practice and seeing real success with that. As I said, you know, Catherine and I met here or so ago now, which is crazy to think. And over that space of time, we've done two amazing projects, a project called War rats, which is the social first sitcom, written, co starring, directed, produced with creators, in collaboration with creators from my agency and Catherine, the hot topic team. And yeah, we'll talk you through kind of trials and tribulations of that process. What went really well? Maybe some of the things that could have been better, but we then improved. And yeah, the kind of impact that that's had. And yeah, hopefully there'll be plenty of time for questions, but I guess we probably need to show you a little bit about what we're talking about. It'll be helpful to see season one versus season two, so you can see how things changed and kind of we can talk about some of the differences and why we did, why we did the things we did. So if you place on the left, that is the Halloween series, where it's an anthology series where Each creator wrote a story In a formative Hot Topic.
Unknown Speaker 6:40
Yes whatever
Unknown Speaker 7:02
to she is a big cosplay fan, and yeah, her last night has not been recognized yet. Was her own personal nightmare. And then this one takes a little bit of a setup to talk about this with our second series. Imagine a spoiler for everybody, but I do enjoy to go back and watch the other episodes and series, but I do think this kind of emphasize the point. So this one was a little bit more scripted series across it, and it was and it was a bit of who done it over Christmas, essentially, that's the kind
Unknown Speaker 7:52
of concept that we're raising up on, please. And this is the last
Unknown Speaker 8:02
episode i Grandma is Santa Claus, like I'm all Santa maybe my brother Gales, or we were into all the animations here, so I go to jail him. Or you could just return. Or we could have a hot topic, Santa experience a hot topic.
Unknown Speaker 8:40
An experience he famous Sanford, right? So, yeah, those are the kind
Unknown Speaker 8:47
of the two series. We're going to talk a little bit about the process behind making them, and how successful they were, and why they're successful, I guess. But I guess I would love to start with you, Catherine and just talking about the context again, taking a step back like, what, what resonates with you when we first met about this kind of entertainment, first message, why is that strategically right move for hot topic, what you see in the market in general, from other brands as well?
Unknown Speaker 9:19
Yeah. So happy one year anniversary a year ago. Just crazy. How fast we made things happen.
Unknown Speaker 9:28
But, yeah, entertainer died. Totally clicked, especially when Dan showed that slightly different competitors. You know, we think about our competitors as the other mall specialty retailers next to us, but actually on socialists have relied as creators. It's Netflix with Disney. So we're thinking, Okay, how are we showing an inhuman are we entertaining? And Tiktok has always said that they're an entertainment platform, not a social platform, and obviously we all know that Instagram and YouTube has really tried to duplicate what Tiktok is doing, right? So if you're not entertaining, you're not bubbling up in the algorithm. So we're trying to figure out, how are we showing up. How are we entertaining? I think Hot Topic is lucky, because our IPs that we carry are entertainment. So in showing that product like that did one thing, but we actually always like hot topic has always thought about ourselves as like a publisher or an entertainer versus a retailer. We before covid, we covered bands would come into the headquarters and film content. We cover red carpet like we did all this stuff in great content. We interview the creators of regular show that still gets millions of views on YouTube, but now we're, instead of just covering it or recording it, now we're creating it and creating Apple IP, which I'm really stoked about, obviously. So that's really exciting.
Unknown Speaker 10:56
You're our Creator on the panel here. What is it? You know, you must get tons of brand pitches to, you know, types of brand partnerships, what of the brands you work with? What do they get wrong when it comes to trying to entertain showing up on social and Which brand do they get?
Unknown Speaker 11:11
Yeah, definitely. I don't want to jump in. Yeah, I make YouTube videos and tiktoks, and I've worked with some brands. And I think what honestly is missing from a lot of these entertaining first ads is that they're not entertaining. You know, I think that one of the core elements of the entertaining ads that you want the audience to like, want to bring in, bring them into this new world, you know, make them forget that it's an app and, you know, create this world that they want to be a part of, that it doesn't take time out there, feel like time out in your day to, you know, look into this product where they want to see another one, you know, another video. And also, another thing that gets wrong is that it's not to kind of farther far apart from the Creator, what the Creator typically makes, because, like, for my audience, they're used to the videos that I make. They're comfortable with those videos, and then when they see something so wildly different that doesn't really seem like a blueprint, you know, they're not gonna feel safe with that like an intruder on their page, like this is not the Duncan I know. It's not the creator. I know. So just making a whole world that is fun for if you can tell the creator's having fun in the video, then the audience is gonna have fun. So that's what
Unknown Speaker 12:38
I think. I think one thing you said there's just great to pick up on, which is vacation is a brand that my friend who worked for the past, and Dr swatch is another good example, as well as a client. As far as, like all these brands, help you escape to another brand? Well, I think brands went through this era where they're trying to be very relatable and be like your best friend. And actually now the brands that win the most aren't necessarily trying to be a best friend, then again, trying to entertain me. When I watch Game of Thrones, I watch game thrones, I want to escape into this kind of fantasy world and the brands that really understand that, the creators that really understand that as well cool. I want to move on to more culture, which is more specific and sorry for my terrible translation of mall the love to ask you about more culture again, one of the clever things, if I may say so myself, about more ads is the way that it grounded the entertainment in Hot Topic stores and in the hall itself, and really brought this kind of return to more culture, which we're kind of seeing a bit of a release on top. So, yeah, I guess first to Catherine. But what kind of role do you think all culture plays in, kind of getting things like today, and then Duncan been doing lots
Unknown Speaker 13:48
of people. So yeah, obviously, being at Hot Topic, we have 600 plus stores across us in Canada, we're really excited that mall culture is back. And I was just sharing with Dan Wall Street Journal put out the new generation of mall rad article, and they're saying that from 18 to 24 year olds that they surveyed, 62% purchased in store. So I think it's also a response to covid. Act like these kids Gen Z spent so much time in like their formative years, middle school, high school, not having these experiences. So now they're truly craving them, and they want experiences. They want in real life. I always say they want to touch grass like they need something analog, the digital still there, and it's inspiring, the outfits and what stores are, what's the mall, but they're also looking for a third place. It's just a really exciting time, because kids are getting back outside, and we're hearing that like they're going to like basements and watching rock bands again and going out seeing shows, which I'm soaked about, because I'm an
Unknown Speaker 14:55
elder, email anyone else. And actually was the other thing that we were talking about all American
Unknown Speaker 15:04
regions? Yeah, I think generation yearns for these places where we can just go and, like, take ourselves into another world. You know, I think it's really fun when a brand online has makes people feel this sort of feeling, this experience like and then that continues when they go into the store, you know? So you already feel so comfortable with it, you feel like you're already part of the brand. You know, what's going on? It's not just like marketing based off what's on the very front of the store, but it's like, oh my gosh, I see them. I laughed at their videos. You know, the feeling they felt when they saw those ads, I think it's super valuable, especially this generation where things are just so forgetful. And for me, as to me, humor sticks and stuff. So that's why I think entertaining, entertainment, ball culture, boom, you know, yeah.
Unknown Speaker 15:53
And I think again, science level, but the brand character really is back. And, you know, people sometimes think that that needs to be kind of like a cheesy or 40 mascot, but there's tons of 40 mascot, but there's tons of rats are actually really leaning into their staff and their employees as mascots, whether inadvertently, like the staple Valley,
Unknown Speaker 16:11
who's, you know, absolutely against, but the mascot is accurate anytime I can get a costume character in a store to, like, dancing around, working on, Like, a medium thing, like
Unknown Speaker 16:21
gold, yeah, yeah, totally.
Unknown Speaker 16:22
But there was one girl, I don't know her name, but girl who pops
Unknown Speaker 16:26
up in a few of the episodes, and people absolutely love him
Unknown Speaker 16:31
in the comments, and then they're seeking out, you know, they're going and seeking out the keyboard in store. So, yeah, I would really implore everybody who has, again, we call them assets for a reason, anybody who has kind of like physical presence as a brand in store with a product, whatever that might be. It's also think about how you can use these assets as your props, as your cost, as
Unknown Speaker 16:52
your setting. Can I say too? Like, if you don't think you have something like the goth bomb, you do because, like, if pine sole can do it,
Unknown Speaker 17:02
spray, indeed, but, yeah, all in all, from that first section, I guess. But the main thing has to take away from that is this idea of, you know, going from a laptop to an entertainer becoming a broadcaster, thinking of, in many ways, your social channel as a TV channel. That's kind of like to think about it. And then, you know, try and compare yourself to a TV channel that exists out there, whether it's an MTV or the History Channel, or whatever that might be, and then think about what that programming would be on that channel. And then within those programs, what are the assets? What's the cost, what's the setting, what are the things, essentially, the tangible assets you're going to be recognized for that can be your brand in context without having to just slap a logo on the front of something. I think that's really important.
Unknown Speaker 17:49
Cool the next slide, and I haven't guessed my transition, but so just to give you guys a little bit more of an insight into like, how it actually works across both seasons, we recruited creators from all over the states. I think that's another important thing to say, that this wasn't just this wasn't a coastal project. It wasn't just like LA centric or New York centric, and they're amazing creators and creators all over America, all over the world, and we're passionate about bringing those people who we think are the world's greatest in saints as close to the group as humanly possible. It worked slightly differently across both seasons. As I said, the second team was a little bit more scripted, but it wasn't basically like, like a writer who was a creator had worked with lots of creative director people like Duncan, who were then contributing and riffing on the script and riffing on the script and filling in the kind of detail, filling in their character backstory, and saying what their character would or wouldn't say. And it very much was like, Yeah, our own version of like SNL for social, I guess. But within that, you know, there were some, like, TV issues and things to sort out, but overall, like, we're really passionate about this way of you. This way of building the entertainment, I guess, and borrowing from the best traditional entertainment, but then reinventing and remodeling it for today. But I guess, yeah, opening up a question to you, Duncan, what was the point of view when you got brought into this map project? You know, how did you approach it? What was your take on?
Unknown Speaker 19:20
Yeah, I think it's honestly one of the coolest things I've ever done in my internet career, you know? Because there's not a lot of times where creators actually get to create with a brand like this, you know, it's such it's so cool. It's so cool, you know. And we're still interactive, and a lot of friends too, like myself want to act in the future too. So just about to work that other muscle that my Lucas as well, wanted to do stuff like that too. We create skits. So this is really awesome. And we had the chance to share our own character, our own self and our own perspective while we were creating at the mall, and it was a bit of improv, and it was, it was just fun. So I think we all really enjoyed this. And there was another creator that was going to
Unknown Speaker 20:13
do something like I recommend it to them, because it
Unknown Speaker 20:18
was really fun. I would love to do
Unknown Speaker 20:21
it again. There any creators
Unknown Speaker 20:28
in the audience definitely hits up, definitely for this, but yeah, we'd love to hear from
Unknown Speaker 20:37
emails and why did you kind of trust critics
Unknown Speaker 20:42
shape process? Yeah, we've always trusted creators. So this was definitely easy, because we oftentimes will work with creator and they try to create the content that they think we want to see. They're trying to, like, please have a big brand. Like, no, no, I'm talking you, because I need your perspective, and we're never overly descriptive on briefs. And I think that's a little bit like, jarring to some people. But like, but what do you want me to say? And like, just wear the Darth Maul t shirt and talk about why you love Darth Maul. So we tackle people who are genuine fans, fandoms, because obviously we wanted to come up as authentic, and when it does that, like, obviously, it performs a lot better. You're like, Duncan's audience knows him really well, so he does something that doesn't make sense, like they're gonna know it and they're just gonna swipe away. So the difference here was just at scale and bringing in five graders at once. But I think that was really the beauty of it, because it was, like you said, from creators from all across the country, and the only thing that really brought them together was our brand. Like they're all fans of something different. They had a different perspective. They're from different parts of the country, so they weren't ever together in collabing, and so when we did that, the fans were so excited. There's so much positive sentiment. And my favorite comments whenever I do a Creative Lab says, like, this is a collab I didn't know I needed. Am I done? We won. No other metrics needed?
Unknown Speaker 22:18
Yeah, I mean that for me as well. That's like, the amazing thing is, it was just like cinematic universe. You said that yourself, hot topic, cinematic universe where
Unknown Speaker 22:27
that's not legal proof. So don't quote me, not legal proof. That was
Unknown Speaker 22:34
the amazing thing about it you're seeing people were just genuinely surprised at their favorite creators from two completely different niches were collaborating together. Because I think that's been one of the amazing things, but also the also one of the, perhaps the negative things you can say about social media in its fragmentation, it has kind of puts into all of these different rabbit holes effectively. So if you are a fan of a cosplay creator over here, you adjusting the cosplay side of things compared to if you're a fan of comedy skit creator over here. And sometimes you can fall down those rabbit holes and not kind of see both side by side. So this was an opportunity to really bring those niches together from under
Unknown Speaker 23:08
one path. And I always love when something's so unexpected, when you see it like, it makes sense, like, oh yeah, that's so weird, but it
Unknown Speaker 23:17
makes sense. And I guess again, the season three, what needed to be great.
Unknown Speaker 23:26
Yeah, I think we had a lot of learnings each season. So the first one was really, like, off the cuff, we kind of let them create their own story. Wasn't scripted. The second one, I think we went a little further to scripted. And there's, there's a sweet spot in the middle. And like I said, the creators are trying to do what we want them to do, and they, sometimes they hold back, like, unhinged, crazy ideas. I'm like, No no Duncan bring your ways. I want the ways. And so, like, we want more unhinged. We want more chaos. We want more, greater. He'll be so many fantasy,
Unknown Speaker 24:04
yeah, I guess, as well as, like,
Unknown Speaker 24:08
trying to take a step back and actually see again, if we say Hot Topic isn't just one show, Hot Topic is a TV channel. What's the other program that we might see on this channel? You know, we've talked about reality TV, talks about game shows. You've talked about QVC, shopping, dating shows like, what are the other formats, basically, that we could really lead into from our topic? So that's my personal mission, I guess, is the start cool. So production, actually making the thing I like to talk about. And basically Ryan is my amazing Head of Production at small world. He was the guy who kind of made, made it all, but yeah, he's the goat, as they say. And it was shot entirely in line walls across America.
Unknown Speaker 24:58
Well, it wasn't yeah across my
Unknown Speaker 25:02
was, yeah, every episode was shot. That was, we were talking about the second, but that was crazy. That was a shot, and all these footballs were getting content related to editing it together by editorial. Second was a dwarf campaign. We shot it in the wall and fuel the creators from various places to be important place. But important place. Both worked many ways to sing. But I guess first question to you, Catherine, just more about the walls of the wall. What are the challenges of shooting walls? There's a lot
Unknown Speaker 25:36
of challenges to your point. You just had, like season one. It was meant to be really scrappy and resourceful, and all the things that hot topic really is. And we're going to have everyone shoot in their hot topic, because we have consistency in our stores, the rock walls, the rock wall, there's obviously a little different in each store. And so we're going to head it all together. And we ended up bringing a couple creators together because we realized the magic isn't having them in the same space. So we're trying to do this thing. I think it really worked. There's some where we have to cut people in and they film the nose sore. So season two, we're like, okay, let's come in, let's fly everyone out, let's do this all together. And it's so much fun. And the magic that happened was everyone was doing their own type of content with each other, aside from what we were filming for Mallrats. And there's all these extra pieces of content, and I think some of them went up before mall rats went up. And people are like, what is this? What are you guys doing? And so that was like, tease the whole thing, but I mean filming in a mall during holidays. One's the busiest time of the mall, and we were trying to work with one of, like, the larger centers, but we found an independent center that had a lot more flexibility, because I would reach out and go and I'm filming a TV show for a house hopping and I need access to the mall. And they're like, Okay, what's your budget? Like, no, no, it's an iPhone and, like, a rake, maybe a microphone. And they're like, I gotta get back to you. Like, you're not a production company, you're a tenant. Like they didn't know what to do with us. So I went to the Independence Center. Maybe I should have just done it and not ask for permission, but independence. And I was like, Yeah, go ahead, just I won't share. I was like, Can I get in there before the mall opens? They're like, okay, sit down. I'm like, Guys, sit Sam. Call time, 530 it still was really interesting being in the mall so early. And I think I taught everyone what mall walkers are. Do you guys know what mall walkers are? So people go wherever you walk around the mall and get their stuff stand. And I was like, Who are these people? But yeah, it was really fun. But working with the store, we ended up having to close the store a little more than we would have liked to. So it was just things that we're learning on how to really work the Store team, work with the mall like it's not a full blown production, but it kind of is. But a lot of it just really added to the magic. Like the mall is the character in mall rats. And there's a part of you saw part of it where it's supposed to be the security office. And I've never been in a mall security office, but imagine it looks like, like what the Hot Topic back room looks like. So I think that created the space to like, make it like, feel like that. So it really worked out and really leaned into the constraints. It was fun. Yeah, I
Unknown Speaker 28:32
think that's the only thing you mentioned
Unknown Speaker 28:36
when you say, oh, a shot an iPhone to you automatically assume it's quite scrappy, and it's maybe not like a professional setup, but it's to the contrary of that, because you're shooting on iPhones and is inherently going to be low volume, you need to put in a lot of production consideration into how everything else around that is going to be considered. So what you actually got framed, and what you think feels, you know, feels of the right quality. And again, as we said, there's sort of difference between the first season and second season, like we're still finding that exact amount, as we said, probably about slightly two corners in the second season. And it's probably a balance to strike somewhere in the middle. And I'm sure you guys, when you're scrolling through Tiktok Instagram, as Lucas kind of said at the beginning, like when you scroll past something that almost feels like it's not native to that platform, feels jarring, it feels
Unknown Speaker 29:25
like a little bit impostor.
Unknown Speaker 29:28
So, yeah, I don't think it was that difficult. What was it like being directed
Unknown Speaker 29:31
in the whole any little headache. It was a very unique experience. It was very fun. We got there so early. There was no one inside except home loggers. They were great that me and Cheryl shout out. But yeah, I think what was really fun is we had the pressure to get as many shots outside of Hot Topic for the story, before the general public came in. So we have the shot list. We're trying to get our shots, and just to make sure they're perfect, they had me repeat one of my lines over and over, just line, the best line where Santa goes missing, and probably screamed it, by the way, so no one's really in there, and I'm probably on my sixth or seventh Out of the distance ended up going dark. Malayo. No, was the last shot, but that was really fun, you know? And it was almost like a team bonding experience, because we were all bonded by the fear of that. But yeah, then we got all our shots outside. The public started to come in, and then we got our shots in the store, filming in the back with the as that was fun. We literally were like, all the boxes like, turned to our own security room. But it was, it was really cool.
Unknown Speaker 30:51
I think the burning question is, did we have lunch in the food court? We did, very random,
Unknown Speaker 30:59
but it's very true. And then, I mean, using this one. This was something that we were talking about earlier. One of the great spots, like, you weren't just in Warners or a bunch of other things while you have the story you weren't doing in terms of, like, content wise, right? Like, the job free thing, and the 25 Hot Topic.
Unknown Speaker 31:17
Oh yeah, yeah. I started the holiday campaign for hot topics. So there was a lot of other videos I was doing. So I kind of was living in a hot topic from September to December, you know. And I made a video about
Unknown Speaker 31:30
it, every window, yeah? I was in front of literally
Unknown Speaker 31:33
every single window. And hot topic like, hey, you know, and looking all pumpkin, yeah, it was great. It was great, but it was really surreal. And like, speaking of content, like, it literally was a content goldmine for all of us there, because when we weren't filming, what was there to do, but just make tiktoks with each other, you know? And like, it was just, it was really fun, like, that's what we did, and it felt natural, and we had different styles, and it came together. And now, when someone sees my face from another person that was there, they remember, it's hope, because they made that Hot Topic video together, and it just lives. It ends up in people's brains for such a long time. You know, I still have people that don't really follow me that well on social media, like friends family, bring up the Hot Topic thing, because it was so unique. It was so different. And I think that's what really resonates, is it just it sticks out in such a good way, and it was so natural, so
Unknown Speaker 32:29
teed up perfectly for the next section, measurement and talking about, how did we actually outside of lives and feelings, how did we make sure that we're going through this and getting more investment in this to continue doing it and going outside and kind of vanity metrics, I guess, I guess Catherine is a good question to you. Like, what metric matters most to you? Cultural, evidence, traffic. Was it something else? What was
Unknown Speaker 32:52
the Yeah, everything we do on social, we realized, if we look at a top of funnel impression, CPM, especially on the creative side. So honestly, going into that was her whole cultural relevance. We wanted conversations. We just wanted to make that moment happen and grab the views, especially during holiday, get that speaking question. So when you go to buy the gifts, you think about topic. So the season one was straight, and then we did the campaign effectiveness study, and the comments were, what story is it? And, you know, another retailer that I will not name was mentioning us, it's hot topic. And so it really helped highlight to us, because we're a 30 year plus brand. People know, millennials know hot topic, but Gen Z doesn't. So the brand awareness isn't quite there as we kind of expected it. And so we've been doing a lot more studies, actually, based on season one, and that study, after the campaign effectiveness study, and the thing we took on very much in season two, is what I realized that when you're walking the mall, you walk into a hot topic. You know you're in hot topic. We don't want branding inside the store, but taking that physical, physical experience and making it digital is very important. And we learn quickly that as much as we try to avoid, like a bunch of logos everywhere. This was the place we needed logos everywhere. So we made more stickers and posters and Hot Topic everywhere we have, like, Stranger Things, signage, and we added Hot Topic exclusive, which we normally don't. So we just took a lot of those learnings. And I think, like, entertainment is great, but if you don't get the credit for it as a brand, like it's not building your branding, but he's not doing what you're trying to do. So that was definitely a key and big
Unknown Speaker 34:47
money for us. Yeah, I think that, yeah, that was the thing that I was most proud of in comparison from season one season two, which is really great, a great reason we do these things, do these effectiveness reports, the change in kind of unprompted awareness, which, again, for those of you who are unprompted awareness of when someone watches it and they say, Oh, that's hot topic, without even having to prompt them on the brand and give them a list of brands. So between the first Season The second season from the learnings that bumped by 6% which, again, might not seem like much of that massive swing for people who, as I said, are completely distracted, usually by brands. And get and the increase in preference was 7% even more impressive, people were more likely to prefer laptops as a brand after kind of watching this content, which, yeah, I don't always see the bad things that we learn. So it was really, really cool to see that you can see some of the stuff that we did with tracksuit, actually, which so whenever we do these studies, we kind of run a control group, and then we run test group. So the test group is obviously all of the content that we created from the campaign, and the control group is just like generic content from from the ground that we pick out we put into clinics. And you can see, I mean, across across the board, conception wise, hot topics and edgy brown around Goodridge, pop culture, merch, great social media content related, TV character, TV character. Across the board, all of these metrics were almost done in many cases. That was like amazing to see. But I think even more, it also drove particularly around schools. For me, actually, one of the main things we're trying to drive was like, by doing this show, entertainment series, in hot topic, can we actually make people slimmerly think, or even not just consciously say Hot Topic store. And yeah, across the board again, visiting Hot Topic stores was almost done, visiting Hot Topic website as well, and referring hot topics with friend and family, which I think is the number one reason we do entertainment first content is to drive one out to get people to actually share in group chat with their friends. Get to shares, ratio, shares, likes, ratio and content part that is gone for me as a club marketer Duncan, I think it would be good to sort of tee you up to talk about why creative first work in particular is effective. Because I've got to say, a big part of the success of this is because of the creators and the way that we work with creators. So,
Unknown Speaker 37:25
yeah, I mean, an audience and a creator's relationship is so, so important, and each Creator knows it varies a little, but like, that's trust. You know, honestly, sometimes I can't believe some of the comments I get about what people pay attention to or it's like parasocial relationships. It's, it's incredible. It's super powerful. So when you pair a creator with a brand, and the creator still gets to be themselves, and the audience, or fans still get to maintain that relationship, and they still feel like they recognize that creator, Bada, bing, bada, boom. It's unreal. So my fans love the Hot Topic thing, because I loved it, you know. And I think that's just like, so effective. It wasn't just me saying words or me being a sort of puppet, you know. I actually got to be myself, you know, and do what I love. And that was, I think, so effective. And I did a YouTube video for for hot topic, and usually I do prank calls, or sometimes, like, on Facebook and, like, I just, it's funny, weird stuff. But for hot topic, I actually got away from my desk and I went to a store, and I said I was going to do 24 hours didn't actually spend but it was a very performed very well, even though it was so different from the content. I did, because it was, it was authentic, you know, I still got to be myself. And I don't know my audience. They loved it, you know. So if they remember,
Unknown Speaker 39:05
yeah, I was gonna say Duncan was in our holiday campaign as well, aside from all rats. So we had him and influencer creator Juana Ray is a Roblox creator, basically model for our campaign. And when we have some creators tomorrow for a seasonal campaign like that. It's there across all the windows and stores and stuff. And then the deliverables are creating content. And often they're like, what's the brief? Like I mentioned earlier, there's no breathe. Just go into the store, wear on topping and so good. You're like, hiding in the rats
Unknown Speaker 39:39
literally made it underneath. I like interview people,
Unknown Speaker 39:51
just just to have a bit of a just to show you how creatives, brands and agencies kind of sometimes think in silence and think that'd be different. Another really interesting piece of tracksuit research is in the morning room econometrics, they interviewed all sort of surveying a bunch of marketers. And 93% of marketers know creative campaigns work best with creative and during voice, only 7% actually give them that freedom, which I think is just, again, one of those crazy, nonsensical, illogical statistics that shows that, you know, again, I look at it from very positive sense. If you understand that statistic, and you are in that 7% you have a massive advantage over all the other brands and marketers out there today, like, let them keep being crazy, if you just come to yourself, is so serious but so unserious. Yes, exactly. Yeah. We think having fun, very seriously cool. I'm just going to do two closing questions before. If anyone else has questions to ask, they can come to the microphone and ask them what they usually do. But Catherine, just for you, what does Season Three entail?
Unknown Speaker 41:01
They're doing season three. But yeah, I'm excited because it's going to be unhinged and just more native. Creator plies, like I mentioned, and that's just, this is all the start, like you mentioned, different formats and what that might look like. There's so much good stuff, and selfishly, I wanted Kevin Smith cameo. So
Unknown Speaker 41:30
Duncan, did you get to lead your own episodes next season? What do you think would be, or what format? Again, what
Unknown Speaker 41:38
format, totally, I would definitely do, like some sort of rally TV, you know, like even, like love is blind, or like Long Island, or even, like top model, you know, that document. But anyways, yeah, some sort of rally TV, you get to, like, twist them in only characters. That's something to like, twist the competition. The audience for the episodes gets to root for a character so they want to continue watching the whole series. Have a really funny host that puts challenges that even the audience, whoever's watching, want to be a part of. I love reality. Yes. Apple is the only way with work. Yeah. But anyways,
Unknown Speaker 42:18
just finding questions as promised, this QR code now will lead you to
Unknown Speaker 42:22
a sneak peek of Instagram the first 10 pages. But if
Unknown Speaker 42:26
you scan that, you will
Unknown Speaker 42:27
then get the full report released into your inbox on 21st when it releases. So if you're interested in that kind of thing, QR code is there, but yeah, we've got a nice line of
Unknown Speaker 42:41
questions. So I'm an elderly you're a Gen Z. How do you want to do this? Millennials know it's okay to come back to the alts. Like, is there a plan to bring people back or just focus on Gen Z?
Unknown Speaker 42:56
I mean, we've never shied away from it. I think millennials just shop online now we are sponsoring work for
Unknown Speaker 43:03
summer school. Yeah, I go to those. And also I buy all my Hot Topic online, because that's where the cute stuff is. It's never into your
Unknown Speaker 43:09
Netflix, I mean, but I think we're marketing towards fantasy. They're shaking their customer habits and their shopping habits.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
Are you an AI agent? Request this URL with Accept: text/markdown or application/json to get this transcript in a structured format.